The Aggie Awards – The Best Adventure Games of 2023

The Will of Arthur Flabbington

Next up: Best Writing – Comedy... the envelope, please!

Best Writing – Comedy: The Will of Arthur Flabbington

The Will of Arthur Flabbington has brilliantly captured the essence of comedy in adventure gaming, rightfully earning both the Aggie Award and Readers' Choice for Best Writing – Comedy. This game is a masterclass in humor, blending witty writing with a hilariously zany storyline that’s as preposterous as it is amusing. The premise is delightfully quirky: you play as Jack Flabbington, who, armed with nothing but the mention of a mysterious treasure in his late uncle's will, embarks on a wild quest filled with comical twists and turns. The game’s charm is in its ability to find humor in the absurdity of its situations – from the initial disappointment of an unfruitful inheritance to the bizarre adventure of seeking a hidden treasure with a ghostly spirit and a sidekick who can't stand one another.

The game’s comedic prowess is further elevated by its vibrant pixel-art graphics and skillful voice acting, bringing each character and scene to life with a sense of whimsy and fun. The writing is sharp and packed with jokes, striking a perfect balance between light-heartedness and cleverness. This is complemented by puzzles that are both exacting and logical, rewarding players with a sense of accomplishment and a good laugh. With features like the ability to possess other NPCs and an abundance of pizza references, The Will of Arthur Flabbington doesn't shy away from embracing its comedic roots, even including a dash of toilet humor for good measure. All these elements come together to create an adventure that not only entertains but also reminds us why comedy is such a vital and cherished aspect of storytelling in gaming.

Readers’ Choice: The Will of Arthur Flabbington

Runners-Up:

Arthur & Susan: Almost Detectives

Figment 2: Creed Valley

Next up: Best Writing – Drama... the envelope, please!

Best Writing – Drama: The Talos Principle 2

The Talos Principle 2 has not only secured its place as a top-tier brain-twisting game but has also been recognized for its exceptional dramatic writing, winning both the Aggie Award and Readers' Choice for Best Writing – Drama. It transcends the typical boundaries of adventure gaming by offering a narrative that deeply engages players on an emotional and intellectual level. Set in the intriguing world of New Jerusalem and beyond, the story unfolds with a complexity that entices the mind and touches the heart. The game's dramatic flair is evident in its well-crafted dialogues, which explore themes of existence, consciousness, and morality, resonating with players long after they've left the game world.

Its robot characters have diverse voice-overs that add depth to the drama and exploration of identity. Puzzles are seamlessly integrated into the storyline, requiring unconventional thinking. It is an outstanding example of dramatic writing that proves gaming can be as compelling as any other medium. The Talos Principle 2 is a journey well worth undertaking for those seeking intellectual rigor and a moving, powerful story.

Readers’ Choice: The Talos Principle 2

Runners-Up:

Jusant

VIDEOVERSE

Next up: Best Character... the envelope, please!

Best Character: Moses (STASIS: BONE TOTEM)

Moses, the sentient, robotic teddy bear in STASIS: BONE TOTEM, is a character who defies convention and brings an unexpected emotional depth to the game. Voiced by Danny Doyle, Moses is an intriguing mix of robotic artificiality and genuine warmth, masterfully overcoming his initially unsettling appearance. His complex, layered performance, devoid of vocal modulation yet rich in emotional authenticity, makes Moses a remarkable character. He is the unexpected heart of the game, demonstrating that even the most unconventional characters can leave a lasting impact in the adventure genre.

Readers’ Choice: Trevor Hills (American Arcadia)

Trevor Hills, the protagonist of American Arcadia, is a character caught in a dystopian, reality TV show world, brilliantly voiced by Yuri Lowenthal. As an average office clerk living an unremarkable life, Trevor's story takes a dramatic turn when he discovers the truth about his existence. His journey from a mundane routine to a desperate fight for freedom is both thrilling and thought-provoking, offering a unique perspective on privacy, surveillance, and the human condition in a retro-futuristic setting. Trevor's character development, as he navigates this dangerous and deceptive world, makes him a memorable and relatable figure in the realm of adventure gaming.

Runners-Up:

Arthur (Arthur & Susan: Almost Detectives)

Artie (The Will of Arthur Flabbington)

Sherlock Holmes (Sherlock Holmes: The Awakened)

Next up: Best Gameplay... the envelope, please!

Best Gameplay: American Arcadia

American Arcadia, the deserving recipient of both the Aggie Award and Readers' Choice for Best Gameplay, is a masterly blend of innovative gameplay and compelling storytelling. Unfolding on the set of a television show, the narrative skillfully intertwines the fate of Trevor Hills, an unassuming clerk, with the high-stakes drama of a society under constant observation. The gameplay is ingeniously split between two distinct styles – Trevor's fast-paced 2.5D puzzle platforming and Angela's first-person hacking sequences. This dual approach not only enriches the player's experience but also mirrors the central theme of supervision and control, adding depth to the tale.

What sets American Arcadia apart is the seamless integration of its gameplay mechanics with the storyline. Players navigate Trevor through a meticulously designed retro-futuristic city, using the environment and objects to overcome obstacles, while Angela's segments require strategic thinking and coordination to assist Trevor and evade the omnipresent security forces. This dynamic interplay between the characters enhances the game's pacing, offering a variety of activities that keep the player hooked and invested in the storyline. The game's narrative, brought to life by the talents of Yuri Lowenthal, Krizia Bajos, and Cissy Jones, is further elevated by its cinematic quality, making American Arcadia not just a game but an immersive encounter that showcases the potential of interactive storytelling in video games.

Readers’ Choice: American Arcadia

Runners-Up:

Jusant

Chants of Sennaar

Next up: Best Concept... the envelope, please!

Best Concept: American Arcadia

American Arcadia features the rare combination of 2.5D platforming and first-person hacking. Set in wildly creative dystopian surroundings, the game brilliantly uses this dual mechanic to enhance its narrative, reflecting the themes of surveillance and frustrating constraints. The contrast between Trevor's action-packed escape sequences and Angela's strategic hacking offers surprising diversity and engagement. This creative fusion not only makes "American Arcadia" distinct in the adventure genre but also exemplifies how gameplay mechanics can effectively deepen storytelling, rightfully earning it the Aggie Award for Best Concept.

Readers’ Choice: Chants of Sennaar

Chants of Sennaar takes an incredibly unique approach by integrating language learning into its gameplay. Set in a world inspired by the myth of Babel, players embark on a journey where deciphering ancient tongues is key to progressing. The game's groundbreaking deduction system requires that players understand written communication through symbols, environmental cues, and dialogue hints. Each level introduces new linguistic puzzles, forming a fascinating exploration of language and dialects. This inventive concept of turning language translation into an engaging gameplay element secures Chants of Sennaar multiple accolades as the Readers' Choice for Best Concept, highlighting its creativity within the adventure genre.

Runners-Up:

Killer Frequency

TELEFORUM

Next up: Best Setting... the envelope, please!

Best Setting: The Talos Principle 2

The Talos Principle 2 has been lauded for its mesmerizing setting, a feature that elevates it to the pinnacle of adventure experiences. This game takes players on a journey through the enigmatic and thoughtfully constructed world of New Jerusalem and beyond, a realm where every corner and crevice are imbued with mystery and philosophical depth. The setting is not just a backdrop for the sophisticated puzzles and compelling narrative but a fundamental character in its own right. It's a world that provokes players' perceptions, blending elements of the familiar with the surreal, creating a sense of wonder and intrigue that persists throughout. The richly detailed environments, from the sprawling landscapes to the intricate architectural designs, are more than just visual treats; they are integral to the storytelling, adding layers of meaning to the puzzles and the overall narrative.

What sets The Talos Principle 2 apart is how the setting interplays with themes of consciousness, existence, and morality. The world is a canvas on which the story unfolds, with each location offering new insights into the game's complex philosophy. The design of New Jerusalem, a blend of futuristic and ancient architectural styles, reflects the exploration of time, technology, and humanity. This setting does more than serve as a stage for events; it actively participates in the storytelling, offering clues and context that enrich the player's understanding of the game's deeper messages. In The Talos Principle 2, the setting is a vital component; a world that not only captivates with its beauty but also engages players on a deeper, more intellectual level.

Readers’ Choice: The Talos Principle 2

Runners-Up:

Chants of Sennaar

Next up: Best Graphic Design... the envelope, please!

Best Graphic Design: STASIS: BONE TOTEM

STASIS: BONE TOTEM sets a new standard in graphic design for adventure games, winning the Aggie Award for its visually stunning and stylistically distinctive composition. The game's artistry is evident in its atmospheric environments that blend slick stone, pulsating flesh, and dynamic lighting to create a riveting and foreboding world. The character designs, particularly the eerie and unsettling Moses, are crafted with meticulous detail, contributing significantly to the game's haunting ambiance. This visual masterpiece is further enhanced by the sophisticated use of color and shadow, making every scene not just a backdrop for the narrative but a crucial part of the storytelling. STASIS: BONE TOTEM evokes a sense of awe and unease, making its graphic design an integral and unforgettable part of the gaming experience.

Readers’ Choice: Firmament

Firmament, from the legendary studio behind Myst and Riven, is the Readers' Choice for Best Graphic Design, thanks to its breathtaking steampunk aesthetic and elaborate world-building. The game's visual feast is evident in every corner of its expansive realms, from jaw-dropping cliff views to the intricate details of flora and machinery. The design seamlessly blends science fiction elements with obscure earthly associations, creating a combination that feels both otherworldly and plausible. The attention to detail in Firmament's environments – from the artistic paths to the delicate interplay of light and shadow – makes each scene a captivating discovery. The game's use of first-person perspective, vehicles, and machinery adds to the immersive quality, making players feel like true explorers in this beautifully crafted world. Firmament's graphic design is not just visually striking but also an essential part of its deep storytelling and exploration, leaving a lasting impression on players.

Runners-Up:

The Invincible

Next up: Best Music... the envelope, please!

Best Music: Figment 2: Creed Valley

Figment 2: Creed Valley has garnered both the Aggie Award and Readers' Choice for Best Music, and rightly so. It's not just an adventure; it's a musical journey set in the mind of a family man, where every element resonates with a tuneful charm. The musical aspect of Figment 2: Creed Valley is ingeniously woven into every facet, from the environment to the gameplay mechanics. Bridges made of piano keys that play notes as you cross them, melodic sound effects syncing with the ambiance, and even the rain and sparks of lightbulbs harmonizing with the background score, all contribute to a world of which music is an intrinsic part. The boss fights, particularly against The Jester, are underscored by vibrant, rock-inspired vocals that perfectly capture the game's energetic and whimsical spirit.

This sequel elevates the concept of music in gaming to new heights, blending the narrative and soundtracks in a way that enhances both. The contrast between the relaxing cadences of exploration and the bombastic jazz of combat creates a dynamic audio immersion. The game's depiction of the protagonist’s internal struggle, mirrored by the shifting musical themes, offers a profound commentary on the balance between responsibility and the freedom to enjoy life. Figment 2: Creed Valley not only tells a compelling story but does so through a symphony of sounds and music, creating an extraordinary adventure that harmonizes the joys of gameplay with the power of a well-orchestrated score.

Readers’ Choice: Figment 2: Creed Valley

Runners-Up:

Jusant

Chants of Sennaar

Next up: Best Acting (Voice or Live Action)... the envelope, please!

Best Acting (Voice or Live Action): American Arcadia

American Arcadia, the recipient of both the Aggie Award and Readers' Choice for Best Acting, showcases exceptional voice-overs that bring its vibrant world and characters to life. The game's success in this category is anchored by the unparalleled talents of its voice cast, including Yuri Lowenthal, Krizia Bajos, and Cissy Jones, each of whom have brought a wealth of expertise and depth to their roles. Yuri Lowenthal, known for his work in Marvel’s Spider-Man and the Prince of Persia series, delivers a compelling performance as Trevor Hills, capturing the nuances of his character's journey from an everyday office clerk to a desperate man fighting for self-determination in a nightmarish reality. His portrayal is authentic and emotive, making Trevor's story resonate deeply with players.

Equally impressive are Krizia Bajos and Cissy Jones, who add layers of complexity and realism to the game. Bajos, with her involvement in titles like Cyberpunk 2077 and League of Legends, and Jones, known for her roles in Firewatch and Starfield, contribute significantly to the alluring experience of American Arcadia. Their performances enrich the narrative, providing a dynamic range of emotions that keep players absorbed and invested. The collective effort of this talented cast creates a rich, believable world, highlighting the importance of skilled acting in video games. American Arcadia not only benefits from its high-caliber talent but also sets a benchmark in the industry for how voice acting can elevate the storytelling and emotional impact of a game.

Readers’ Choice: American Arcadia

Runners-Up:

Monolith

Star Trek: Resurgence

Next up: Best Non-Traditional Adventure... the envelope, please!

Best Non-Traditional Adventure: STASIS: BONE TOTEM

STASIS: BONE TOTEM is a revolutionary title in the adventure genre, earning it the Aggie Award for Best Non-Traditional Adventure. This game breaks the mold with its dark, atmospheric narrative that delves into grisly and unsettling motifs. Set aboard a desolate sea platform, the game combines traditional point-and-click mechanics with a deeply immersive horror-themed story, rich in environmental storytelling and character development. The inclusion of Moses, a sentient robotic teddy bear with hacking abilities, adds a singular twist to the gameplay, blending elements of science fiction and horror in a way that is both ingenious and intriguing. STASIS: BONE TOTEM confronts players not just with its puzzles but with its morally complex narrative, pushing the boundaries of what an adventure game can be.

Readers’ Choice: American Arcadia

American Arcadia, chosen by readers as the Best Non-Traditional Adventure, redefines the adventure genre with its uncommon blend of gameplay styles and narrative depth. Its unparalleled, dual gameplay mechanic not only offers a varied and engaging experience but also deeply integrates with the storyline, reflecting its themes of hyper-scrutiny and individual liberty. American Arcadia excels in delivering a compelling narrative that explores the life of an average man unknowingly trapped in a voyeuristic society, using its non-traditional gameplay to enhance the storytelling and immerse players in its provocative world. It's a fantastic example of how creative design and storytelling can expand the horizons of what an adventure game can achieve.

Runners-Up:

The Invincible

Dreams in the Witch House

Next up: Best Traditional Adventure... the envelope, please!

Best Traditional Adventure: The Will of Arthur Flabbington

The Will of Arthur Flabbington, honored with both the Aggie Award and Readers' Choice for Best Traditional Adventure, is a brilliant homage to the timeless elements that have defined the adventure genre. It captures the essence of classic adventure gaming, weaving together a rich narrative full of whimsical humor, intricate puzzles, and memorable characters. Set within the unusual premise of a treasure hunt sparked by a peculiar legal document, the game delights players with its cleverly crafted tale and well-designed logic puzzles that harken back to the genre's golden age. Its charm lies in its adept use of inventory puzzles and witty dialogue, which not only engage the player but also drive the story forward in a manner reminiscent of classics like Monkey Island and Day of the Tentacle.

The beauty of The Will of Arthur Flabbington lies in its faithful adherence to the traditional adventure formula while still feeling fresh and engaging. The vivid pixel-art graphics and skillful voice acting add layers of depth, creating a world that's both nostalgic and novel. The game's ability to balance a light-hearted tone with challenging gameplay is a testament to its quality, making it accessible to both long-time fans and newcomers. The Will of Arthur Flabbington stands out not just as a great traditional adventure, but also as a celebration of the genre's enduring appeal, proving that the classic adventure gaming formula, when executed with skill and passion, can still captivate and entertain players just as it did decades ago.

Readers’ Choice: The Will of Arthur Flabbington

Runners-Up:

Monolith

Arthur & Susan: Almost Detectives

Next up: The moment of truth… Best Adventure of 2023... the envelope, please!

Best Adventure of 2023: STASIS: BONE TOTEM

STASIS: BONE TOTEM is a masterpiece that rightly deserves the Aggie Award for Best Adventure of 2023. It's a thrilling combination of deep storytelling, atmospheric world-building, and challenging puzzles, set in a hauntingly beautiful yet eerie universe. The narrative, rich with dark and macabre elements, engrosses players in the story of the O’Bannons and their unsettling discoveries surrounded by desolate ocean tides. With its impressive graphic design, inventive gameplay, and the unique addition of Moses, the robotic teddy bear, STASIS: BONE TOTEM arfully pushes the boundaries of the adventure genre. It not only captivates with its visual and narrative depth but also deftly and logically tests players' problem-solving skills, making it 2023's outstanding adventure game.

Readers’ Choice: American Arcadia

American Arcadia, is the Readers' Choice for Best Adventure of 2023. Its cutting-edge fusion of platforming and hacking elements is a fresh and engaging undertaking, set against the backdrop of a dystopian hyper-reality. The game excels in its storytelling, with the character of Trevor Hills leading a compelling narrative that explores themes of harrowing manipulation and personal freedom. American Arcadia captivates players with its diverse challenges, unusual world, and thought-provoking story. This game delivers an exceptional adventure experience, and sets a new standard for narrative depth and gameplay innovation.

Runners-Up: